Sanjeev (35), like many others, feel Equity is risky. He’s afraid of seeing RED in his portfolio, even if it is notional and for short term, and thus prefer to invest much of his savings into fixed return instruments like PPF, FDs, RDs etc. Actually he’s inherited such behavior from his father who had always been wary of stock market investments.
Sanjeev has 2 Public provident fund (PPF) accounts, one on his own name and other on his wife’s name. Last year he also opened Sukanya Samriddhi account for his daughter. He is of the opinion that by using the partial withdrawal options in all his investments, he would be able to manage the major goals of his life. His father used to do the same thing in his working years.
But the recent changes announced in Small savings interest rates space made him apprehensive about his goal achievement.
Moreover he is also not sure if his strategy of depending on “TAX FREE” fixed interest instruments would pay in future or not. Budget 2016 provision of taxing EPF raised his doubts. Though the provision has been rolled back but it has shown the intention of the government.
He’s seeking answer of “Is it possible to achieve long term goals by investing in the small savings schemes only?”
Well, Sanjeev’s apprehension is quite genuine. There must be lakhs of other investors who are feeling this way. Before dipping into the question, let’s first understand what changes in small savings interest rates have raised such doubt in his mind.
Revision in Small savings Interest rates w.e.f. 1st July 2017
On 30th June 2017, Ministry of finance came up with revised interest rates on small saving schemes. Rates have been reduced considerably. Below are the details
This is not all, what is more important are the changes in the Reset period of Interest rates. Now onwards the small savings interest rates will be reset and notified every quarter unlike every year earlier. Every March, June, September and December, interest rates will be announced.
Revision in small savings interest rates will be based on FIMMDA (Fixed Income Money Market and Derivatives Association of India) month end Government Securities (G sec) rates for the last quarter.
Small savings Interest rates gets decided on G-Sec rates of the comparable maturity of specific schemes, plus a fixed spread. Spread is the extra rate which government offers above the G-sec rates.
As per the recent changes announced, spread remains the same as earlier in all schemes except in Term deposits of 1y/2y/3y, KVP and 5 year Recurring deposit. In these schemes spread has been reduced to NIL from 0.25%. The Government has tried to keep these schemes at par with bank deposit rates, so in future its rates would be more or less similar to the rates being offered by banks.
Spread in Sukanya Samriddhi account is 0.75% and in PPF is 0.25%, and both follow the same G-sec maturity periods (10y). Thus, if for e.g. FIMMDA last quarter’s month end G-sec rate was 8%, then Sukanya account would earn 8.75% and PPF would get 8.25% in next quarter. Sukanya earns 0.50% higher than PPF.
But do remember that as per new rules, whatever the new small savings interest rates announced will remain same for one-quarter only.
Besides, change in the Reset period and spreads in some schemes, the government has also changed the frequency of compounding in NSC and KVP. Earlier it was half yearly and from 1st April 2016, it would be annually.
How are G-sec rates and Small saving schemes linked with each other?
You must be thinking that what is the connection between G-sec rates and small saving schemes? Why G-sec rates be taken as the benchmark for small saving interest rates?
Before me answering this, let me ask you a question. Let’s assume you need a loan, and you have 2 options:
Bank A offers loan at 8% and Bank B offers at 9%. All terms and conditions are same. Which bank would you prefer? The answer is obvious, right?
Same way if Government can get loan, from market through G-sec at 7.50% for 15 years term, why would it take loan from you through PPF at 8.7%? and every year or every quarter when government ask for loan and finds a new rate, then why would it want to stay fixed on higher one?
Small savings is just a mechanism to borrow from retail clients, and since the government has some social responsibility towards country people, especially as in India where there’s no social security available, so, it ask loan from public with some spread which in turn becomes a saving tool for investors.
The way interest rates have moved in past, the government like all borrowers feel that Floating rate is better than fixed.
G-Sec rates in last 10 years
G-sec papers come in different tenures – 5y, 10y, 20y, 30y. All tenures have different rates. G-sec market is more of an institutionalized, where papers are purchased by banks, Insurance companies, Mutual fund houses, PF trusts, Pension funds, PSUs, other corporates.
To manage liquidity, these papers get traded in the debt market. Depending on the Liquidity requirements, demand and supply, international factors, market interest rates, currency movements, these G-sec papers are valued and traded. Due to trading, the yields keep on varying on daily basis. Just like Share prices, these G-sec rates also move up and down.
The above graph shows the variation in “10 years G-Sec bond rates”, in last 10 years. This will give you an idea, how volatile your small savings interest rates can become in coming years.
From the above graph it is easy to gauge that Period of 2008 – 2010 has shown huge variation. If the Small savings interest rates were G-sec linked in those days, then you could have seen PPF rates @ 9%+ in some quarter and also 5%+ in some.
What should Investors do?
See, since almost all the investment instruments have been market linked now, so active management of the portfolio is what is required. Now from Active management, I don’t mean to go for trading or something, but you need to have such a diversified portfolio that you will be at the gain in all kind of market situations. ( Read: How prepared are you for stock market fall?)
Regular revision of small savings interest rates may not impact much on close ended instruments like Senior citizen savings scheme or National Savings Certificate, as once invested rates would get locked in. But for regular investments product like PPF and Sukanya, this does matter.
With the fall in G-sec yields, PPF interest would also fall, but you can benefit out of this by allocating some portion of investments to long-term Gilt Mutual funds. Interest rates and bond prices are inversely related, so when interest rates fall, Bond prices rise and vice versa.
Just have a look at how actively managed long-term Gilt funds have performed during 2008-10 when we saw sharp movements in G-sec yields as per Graph shown above.
Below is the return graph of 2 of the popular Gilt funds during the same period
It is clearly visible, how long term gilt has performed in falling interest rate scenario. Now here, I am not saying that such situation may repeat in future, and neither am I saying that the referred funds in the graph above are worth buying.
What I am trying to point out, is to have a diversified nonrelated portfolio, so one instrument’s loss could be other instrument’s gain, so your goal achievement should not be hampered. When you are investing in PPF or Sukanya Samriddhi account with long-term view, do look at other long-term debt funds along with. And when your investment horizon is of short to medium term, through NSC or KVP or bank FD, you may also look at the same maturity debt mutual funds portfolio too. ( Read: Asset location is as important as Asset Allocation)
I know what you are thinking. Now you want to know, how to select Gilt funds? How much to Invest in them and when? How can you sense that which side Interest rates are going to go? And above all are gilt funds taxable? Right?
Well, if you are DIY (Do It Yourself) investor, then I am sure you will study hard and find out the answers, but if you are not, then better to have a financial plan first, so you can figure, what is actually required in your overall portfolio. Do you actually require gilt kind of fund or short-term portfolio can help you.
This answers Sanjeev’s point too. No single product can help achieve goals; it is the combination of different unrelated products, based on your Asset allocation decided out of your risk profile and goals targeted, which needs to be there in a Portfolio.
Gone are the days of fixed interest rates for long term. I will not be surprised if you see these tax free instruments going taxable in coming years. You need to have hold on to your money, your investments and should be sure why you are doing what you are doing.
Hope you find this article on Small savings Interest rates useful. By the way how you have planned to deal with these volatile products now? Do share your strategy and queries if any.